Indo-Fijian lawyer may face jail for pointing out spelling error

Prominent Indian-origin lawyer Richard Naidu has been found guilty of contempt and scandalising the court for pointing out a spelling error in a judgement.

Naidu may face a jail-term for his Facebook post in February 2022 in which he posted a picture of a judgement in a case that had the word ‘injunction’ wrongly spelt as ‘injection’.

“Maybe our judges need to be shielded from all this vaccination campaigning. I’m pretty sure all the Applicant wanted was an injunction,” Naidu said in his post with a “thinking face” emoji.

The High Court in Suva gave its decision last week after a complaint by Attorney General, Aiyaz Sayed-Khaiyum, who described Naidu’s post as malicious and inviting others to mock the judiciary, the RNZ reported.

The case will be called on January 5, 2023 to hear sentencing and mitigation submissions.

In Fiji, the sentencing range for contempt of scandalising the court appears to be between three to six months’ imprisonment.

According to law associations and human rights organisations, Naidu’s sentencing is a “violation of the right to freedom of expression”.

Amnesty International said it “believes that the charges are an excessive and politically motivated response to pointing out a spelling error in a court judgment and violate the right to freedom of expression”.

“Pursuing a lawyer with criminal or administrative punishment for pointing out accurately on social media a spelling mistake in a public court judgment is manifestly disproportionate and a violation of his right to exercise his freedom of expression,” the rights group said in a statement.

Kate Schuetze, Amnesty International Pacific Researcher, tweeted that “the charges are ridiculous and should be thrown out!”

In a statement, The Bar Association of India called upon the Attorney-General of Fiji “to forthwith bring the proceedings to a satisfactory closure by causing the conviction to be annulled”.

“The Bar Association of India calls on the Fijian judiciary to respect the right to freedom of expression. The Fijian judiciary’s reputational excellence is not lowered in any way by mere statements or humorous remarks,” Bar Association President, Prashant Kumar, said.

The Law Council of Australia noted in a statement that “Naidu was denied procedural fairness and was not afforded a fair trial”.

Naidu is a long-time critic of the present government in Fiji.

The South Pacific nation goes to polls on December 14.

20221128-094202

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here